Metaphysics Syllabus

Whitman College - Fall 2005
Mitch Clearfield

skip to: [ description ] [ goals ] [ class format ] [ texts ] [ high-tech ] [ requirements ] [ academic honesty ]

The word ‘philosophy’ derives from Greek words meaning ‘love of wisdom’. So philosophy attempts to determine some of the deepest truths about our existence and the reality around us. What distinguishes philosophy is not just the issues that it addresses, since some of these are also addressed by other fields (like science and religion). What is distinctive about philosophy is the way in which it attempts to answer those questions: through reason. Philosophers attempt to justify their views with arguments, laying out the strongest reasons in favor of their positions and responding to the strongest objections against them.

Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that attempts to understand the ultimate nature of reality – what the nature of the world really is, what things the world really does contain, what the different categories of existing things really are, and what relations exist among those things. It considers such basic concepts as existence, identity, possibility, necessity, substance, matter, form, cause, and time.

In this course, we will focus on the metaphysics of persons, and in particular on three issues:

• Personal Identity: What makes me the same person at one time as at another?
• The Self: What exactly am I? Is there really such a thing as a unified self at the core of my existence?
• Free Will: What would it take for me to be genuinely responsible for my own actions? Am I?

In the process, we will also touch on philosophical views related to a number of other metaphysical issues, such as the nature of substance and causation. Throughout the semester, we will be particularly concerned with the interrelations among all of the different issues and views that we examine. We will also consider how these kinds of metaphysical questions relate to questions in other areas of philosophy, such as epistemology (how can our beliefs be justified?) and ethics (how should one live?), and how all of these different branches of philosophy relate to scientific inquiry.

While metaphysics has occupied philosophers for millennia, in this class we will focus on current approaches and theories. This means that we will be examining some difficult and complicated texts in contemporary philosophy. Nonetheless, this course is meant as an introduction to philosophy, and does not assume any prior background (though students with more experience with philosophy should also find it rewarding). We will take the time to make sure that at least the main ideas are clear and accessible to everyone.

1. To explore certain fundamental questions and issues of metaphysics.

2. To gain an understanding of some of the main contemporary approaches to those issues.

3. To develop an appreciation of the relations between metaphysics and other areas of philosophy, and between philosophy and science.

4. To enhance the abilities to read, think, discuss, and write clearly in a philosophical way.

5. To sharpen general interpretive and analytical skills.

Our class meetings will primarily focus on discussion of the readings and the larger issues related to them. As much as possible, you will have a chance to apply and evaluate the ideas that the texts present, and to develop alternatives.

However, because of the nature of the material, I will sometimes need to take time to explain certain issues or aspects of an author’s views, or to present important background or related ideas. Also, I will often take a few minutes at the end of each class to set up the next reading and give you any needed pointers.

• A good dictionary. (You can’t understand the readings if you don’t know what the words mean!)
  
  
• John Perry, A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality (Hackett, 1978).
  
  
• Raymond Martin & John Barresi, eds., Personal Identity (Blackwell, 2002).
  
  
• Clifford Williams, Free Will and Determinism: A Dialogue (Hackett, 1980).
  
  
• Robert Kane, ed., Free Will (Blackwell, 2001).
  
  
• Daniel Wegner, The Illusion of Conscious Will (MIT, 2003).
  

In addition, there are several readings on reserve at Penrose Library, and some that are also available online through the schedule.

• I will often distribute important announcements, reminders, and clarifications through e-mail. It is your responsibility to check your account every day.
  
  
• There is also an e-mail list-server set up for the class, which you should feel free to use. Messages sent to phil270a_05fa@whitman.edu will be forwarded to everyone in the class.
  
  
• This syllabus and a varity of other useful and/or entertaining stuff can be found through the class website: http://people.whitman.edu/~clearfms/metaphysics.htm

Attendance and Participation
You are expected to be an active and productive participant in our meetings. To do this, you must carefully read (and often re-read) the assigned texts before class, and come to our meetings with questions, issues, and ideas to discuss.
The issues and material that we will be examining this semester are quite challenging, and our meetings will surely help you to gain a better understanding of them. Students who are habitually unprepared or absent (either physically or mentally) typically hand in poor work; there will be no additional penalty. On the other hand, if you demonstrate a particularly good grasp of the issues and material in our meetings, your final grade may be raised to reflect that.

Weekly Response Papers — 2/3 of your total grade
As we are considering different issues and approaches this semester, it is important for you to reflect and develop your own thoughts about them. Most weeks you will write a brief essay (650 words maximum) in which you articulate your own view of the class material. More details are available here.

Final Examination — 1/3 of your total grade
There will be a comprehensive take-home final examination, which you will be able to complete at your convenience during exam week. The exam questions will give you an opportunity to demonstrate that you have understood, synthesized, and reflected on the issues and views that we’ve examined throughout the semester. More details will be provided toward the end of the semester.

All of the work that you submit in this course must be entirely your own. Of course, you can seek help in a variety of ways to prepare yourself for the papers and the exam. So it is permitted (and even recommended!) for you to: consult additional readings, search for material on the internet, discuss your ideas with other students, exchange notes with other students, and read and discuss drafts of each other’s papers. If you do use someone else’s words or specific ideas in your written work, you must provide a proper citation to the source.

Plagiarism will not be tolerated in any form. You have signed a statement indicating that you understand and will abide by the College policy on plagiarism. Any student caught plagiarizing will automatically fail the course, and may face more severe penalties from the College. (For more details, see the Student Handbook.)